Brooks help
12-12-12, 06:15 PM
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Bremen, Germany
Posts: 365
Bikes: Poison Chinin IGH
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Can't help with the width but i support the advise to lace your B17. I had one that was stretched too much, and then the bolt failed. I ended up disassembling it, replacing the bolt, butchered, laced and mounted the leather top back using screws and nuts. And I ended up with something I was looking for a while, it's like a wider Swallow. The top part is pretty flat, it's as stiff as B17N (i have that one too) and i really like the width of the regular B17.
It's got a bit wider in the middle, and I can put it further backwards, which helps when i want to sit lower -- i don't need to sit right on top of the metal frame, it's easier to find the sweet spot. I guess it could help you a bit when mountain biking, it is easier to get behind a low saddle. In general i see a pattern with Brooks saddles: the more upright the riders position is, the more flat is the saddle. And it needs to be wider too to support the sitbones (well, sorry for saying the obvious).
Now it is my favorite saddle, I am glad I had a bit of spare time to torture it and did not throw it away.
Photos:
It's got a bit wider in the middle, and I can put it further backwards, which helps when i want to sit lower -- i don't need to sit right on top of the metal frame, it's easier to find the sweet spot. I guess it could help you a bit when mountain biking, it is easier to get behind a low saddle. In general i see a pattern with Brooks saddles: the more upright the riders position is, the more flat is the saddle. And it needs to be wider too to support the sitbones (well, sorry for saying the obvious).
Now it is my favorite saddle, I am glad I had a bit of spare time to torture it and did not throw it away.
Photos:
Last edited by mikhalit; 12-12-12 at 06:42 PM.
12-12-12, 09:50 PM
#27
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 3,150
Bikes: 2013 Surly Disc Trucker, 2004 Novara Randonee , old fixie , etc
Likes: 0
Liked 49 Times
in
43 Posts
Can't help with the width but i support the advise to lace your B17. I had one that was stretched too much, and then the bolt failed. I ended up disassembling it, replacing the bolt, butchered, laced and mounted the leather top back using screws and nuts. And I ended up with something I was looking for a while, it's like a wider Swallow. The top part is pretty flat, it's as stiff as B17N (i have that one too) and i really like the width of the regular B17.
It's got a bit wider in the middle, and I can put it further backwards, which helps when i want to sit lower -- i don't need to sit right on top of the metal frame, it's easier to find the sweet spot. I guess it could help you a bit when mountain biking, it is easier to get behind a low saddle. In general i see a pattern with Brooks saddles: the more upright the riders position is, the more flat is the saddle. And it needs to be wider too to support the sitbones (well, sorry for saying the obvious).
Now it is my favorite saddle, I am glad I had a bit of spare time to torture it and did not throw it away.
It's got a bit wider in the middle, and I can put it further backwards, which helps when i want to sit lower -- i don't need to sit right on top of the metal frame, it's easier to find the sweet spot. I guess it could help you a bit when mountain biking, it is easier to get behind a low saddle. In general i see a pattern with Brooks saddles: the more upright the riders position is, the more flat is the saddle. And it needs to be wider too to support the sitbones (well, sorry for saying the obvious).
Now it is my favorite saddle, I am glad I had a bit of spare time to torture it and did not throw it away.
12-14-12, 05:01 AM
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Bremen, Germany
Posts: 365
Bikes: Poison Chinin IGH
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
not at all, i don't feel any difference between this and original (these bolts have very low profile and wide cap). But it's not really necessary to use'em, i had to do it because of the failed bolt. Sure it was easier to get the right tension with the detached leather part.
I like the look though, reminds me my teenage years.
I like the look though, reminds me my teenage years.
Last edited by mikhalit; 12-14-12 at 05:08 AM.
12-28-12, 02:23 PM
#31
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 185
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
The Team Pro and the B17 Select arrived today. My views on them:
Team Pro- GORGEOUS saddle, but unfortunately not for me. The rails are too short and I can't get it back enough on the seatpost. Also, the shape is too round for me, and the flat section is too short. The leather on mine is 4.5-4.8mm thick, good but nothing crazy. Also, the width difference for the B17 is not enough to make it easier to get behind. Is currently on sale.
B17 Select- This thing is built like a tank. The leather is between 5 to 5.5mm thick, and in some places goes to almost 6mm! Overall shape and rail lenght is the same as my old B17, which is a good thing. The frame finish is much better than the flimsy paint of the Standard models. I'll keep this one
Team Pro- GORGEOUS saddle, but unfortunately not for me. The rails are too short and I can't get it back enough on the seatpost. Also, the shape is too round for me, and the flat section is too short. The leather on mine is 4.5-4.8mm thick, good but nothing crazy. Also, the width difference for the B17 is not enough to make it easier to get behind. Is currently on sale.
B17 Select- This thing is built like a tank. The leather is between 5 to 5.5mm thick, and in some places goes to almost 6mm! Overall shape and rail lenght is the same as my old B17, which is a good thing. The frame finish is much better than the flimsy paint of the Standard models. I'll keep this one
