Curious if anyone has tried to submit a reckless driving video to police ....?
#26
Video taping close passes, aggressive driving hasn't been a waste of time for me, it has given me the info need to report/document problem motorists to local law enforcement, rather than just my stewing about the incident.
Again, due to our area's disproportionately high motor vehicle/bicyclist/ped collision rate, our local law enforcement takes aggressive/dangerous driving reports very seriously, especially when a considerable amount of their annual funding is tied to how well they are able to reduce the local collision rate.
Again, due to our area's disproportionately high motor vehicle/bicyclist/ped collision rate, our local law enforcement takes aggressive/dangerous driving reports very seriously, especially when a considerable amount of their annual funding is tied to how well they are able to reduce the local collision rate.
#27
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 3,040
Bikes: Bacchetta Giro, Strada
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
Parking tickets are generally given by meter maids -- they're not sworn police officers. They don't have the authority to give moving violation tickets, but they can give civil parking tickets. The fine is assessed to the registered owner of the vehicle rather than the person who actually parked it. Red light cameras work more like meter maids than police officers. The rules are radically different.
So if it's "good" enough for a red light runner why shouldn't it be good enough for more serious offenses?
Also note that the police department rarely has anything whatsoever to do with the red light cameras beyond being caught an awful lot running said red lights.
#28
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Tampa/St. Pete, Florida
Posts: 9,352
Bikes: Specialized Hardrock Mountain (Stolen); Giant Seek 2 (Stolen); Diamondback Ascent mid 1980 - 1997
Likes: 0
Liked 4 Times
in
4 Posts
If criminal charges got to be issued by private citizens, legal chaos would erupt.
Private citizens have no authority to issue criminal charges. criminal accusations, yes.
as to videotaping 'close passes' and 'aggressive passing' and 'violations of 3 foot laws', a bicyclist is going to be putting a lot of energy into non-events in the eyes of the law.
My impression is that only in the most egregious of harassment or endangerment scenarios is a bicyclists video going to garner anything other than suggestions from the police they've got more important things to be dealing with.
like the video of the driver coming at Degnaw posted above. 8 months and no word. That type of complaint is going to simply waste a bicyclists time and energy, unfortunately.
Private citizens have no authority to issue criminal charges. criminal accusations, yes.
as to videotaping 'close passes' and 'aggressive passing' and 'violations of 3 foot laws', a bicyclist is going to be putting a lot of energy into non-events in the eyes of the law.
My impression is that only in the most egregious of harassment or endangerment scenarios is a bicyclists video going to garner anything other than suggestions from the police they've got more important things to be dealing with.
like the video of the driver coming at Degnaw posted above. 8 months and no word. That type of complaint is going to simply waste a bicyclists time and energy, unfortunately.
#29
totally louche
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: A land that time forgot
Posts: 18,023
Bikes: the ever shifting stable loaded with comfortable road bikes and city and winter bikes
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times
in
9 Posts
thank you. if you're trying to be insulting, you need to take it down a notch, and take a look at the forum guidelines.
I do understand some basics about legal process.
a lot of the things considered 'reckless driving' by bicyclists won't get even a whit of attention down at the station.
the action has to be quite egregious for a DA to consider charges.
one of the posters reports frequent reports filed with the police.
I wonder how much success dynodonn has actually had from the frequent dispatches of close passes to the local police.
I do understand some basics about legal process.
a lot of the things considered 'reckless driving' by bicyclists won't get even a whit of attention down at the station.
the action has to be quite egregious for a DA to consider charges.
one of the posters reports frequent reports filed with the police.
I wonder how much success dynodonn has actually had from the frequent dispatches of close passes to the local police.
#30
Arizona Dessert
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: AZ
Posts: 15,029
Bikes: Cannondale SuperSix, Lemond Poprad. Retired: Jamis Sputnik, Centurion LeMans Fixed, Diamond Back ascent ex
Liked 2,169 Times
in
1,288 Posts
It's been eight months since I submitted this video to Presque Isle park rangers, and I still havent received a formal response.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-UN_fRpQcI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-UN_fRpQcI
Acknowledge that an unknown driver of a red vehicle with unknown plates was in incorrect lane (for unknown, but potentially legitimate reasons) and moved back over to their lane in time to avoid you?
#31
As for my garnering success in getting any tickets issued to the motorists that I reported, that would be none. As for my getting the same motorists documented, that would be 100 percent, but that's all I wanted to do in the first place.
#32
Actually, degnaw was able to get the license number with a very good head turn of the camera, the license number is the YouTube title.
#33
I will likely stop by the Police Dept. one of these days, and straight out ask them what type of incidents, and what type of proof, may warrant their attention. They have a fair amount of resources, and the town has made recent efforts to reduce pedestrian (and cycling) incidents.
I simply want to know, for the future, what situations they will take seriously - what is the threshold. And, as many have discussed, I'm sure the threshold is dramatically different based on your region, biases, and resources.
I simply want to know, for the future, what situations they will take seriously - what is the threshold. And, as many have discussed, I'm sure the threshold is dramatically different based on your region, biases, and resources.
#34
Cycle Year Round
In general the red light camera tickets are civil actions -- like parking tickets -- where tickets given by police officers are infractions or the lowest level of misdemeanor.
Of course, some states may be different -- I'm certainly not familiar with all of them -- but this is generally how that works.
Of course, some states may be different -- I'm certainly not familiar with all of them -- but this is generally how that works.
__________________
Land of the Free, Because of the Brave.
Land of the Free, Because of the Brave.
#35
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 3,040
Bikes: Bacchetta Giro, Strada
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
Texas too, and probably quite a few other states. (Some states have a level of offense called an "infraction" that's not quite criminal.)
... now, that doesn't include Texas.
Yes, that appears to be the case in California, Colorado and Arizona.
However, "In most jurisdictions the liability for red light violations is a civil offense, rather than a criminal citation, issued upon the vehicle owner—similar to a parking ticket".
Same source as above, "In many California police departments, when a positive identification cannot be made the registered owner of the vehicle will be mailed a notice of traffic violation instead of a real ticket. Also known as "snitch tickets," these notices are used to request identifying information about the driver of the vehicle during the alleged violation. Because these notices have not been filed at court, they carry no legal weight and the registered owner is under no obligation to respond."
Of course, it wouldn't be the first time that a police officer had told somebody that they had to do something when they really did not.
Not that any of this has any bearing on submitting a reckless driving video to the police ...
That includes red light camera infractions in CA.
For those, the drivers face must be identifiable in the picture or the ticket gets tossed.
However, "In most jurisdictions the liability for red light violations is a civil offense, rather than a criminal citation, issued upon the vehicle owner—similar to a parking ticket".
Unless of course the heavy handed camera cop gets the owner of the car to rat out who was driving at the time.
Of course, it wouldn't be the first time that a police officer had told somebody that they had to do something when they really did not.
Not that any of this has any bearing on submitting a reckless driving video to the police ...
#36
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Rural Missouri - mostly central and southeastern
Posts: 3,025
Bikes: 2003 LeMond -various other junk bikes
Likes: 0
Liked 50 Times
in
40 Posts
Yeah - and as usual my comments about whether a "driver" is identified in any submitted video is ignored..... just like complaints from cyclists.... hmmm ...
#37
Senior Member
#38
This is not entirely accurate. There have been a number of times where I've caught up to reckless drivers (i.e. traffic light) and would be able to get a clear shot of their face. I can think of many other examples too, such as people who have intentionally pulled out right in front of me (with their eyes locked on me) and forced me to skid out to a stop. Or how about the officer who right hooked me? Or is he going to say someone else was driving his car too? Or the duo that tried to intentionally push me off the road going 25mph - I'm pretty sure I would have got clear video of the pusher's face considering it was about a foot from my left shoulder!
Last edited by lineinthewater; 04-06-12 at 08:46 AM.
#39
Part-time epistemologist
Locally, people have used video as a tool to report issues with streets, facilities, and so on. Overall, it can be a useful tool and sometimes contribute to a powerful argument.
It's been eight months since I submitted this video to Presque Isle park rangers, and I still havent received a formal response.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-UN_fRpQcI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-UN_fRpQcI
__________________
A narrative on bicycle driving.
A narrative on bicycle driving.
#40
Documentation is important, IMO. And this applies to more than people inside cars.
Locally, people have used video as a tool to report issues with streets, facilities, and so on. Overall, it can be a useful tool and sometimes contribute to a powerful argument.
#41
Shimano Certified
At this point I just have a forward facing handlebar mount unit, but the lack of PA forward plates somewhat negates using a rear for ID of plates. I have been making a score list since I commute the same stretch of road for considerable amounts of days and times. So far the cops have been partnering along the points I requested although it took a couple weeks to get their schedule rolled around. Now they wave and smile when I roll past the speed traps. Even if the extent of the police action was speeding tickets and an occasional personal greeting of the offender with a question it would still send a message. Tort and charges would be perhaps vengeful even if it would be justified to law. At least 2/3 of the near miss-ers that I have been able to talk to have not repeat offended. Even my little vivitar DVR 480 is mostly effective at scoring license plates. I wouldn't spend much more than $20 on a camera for it, but it works and its a good help for the memory.
#42
totally louche
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: A land that time forgot
Posts: 18,023
Bikes: the ever shifting stable loaded with comfortable road bikes and city and winter bikes
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times
in
9 Posts
At this point I just have a forward facing handlebar mount unit, but the lack of PA forward plates somewhat negates using a rear for ID of plates. I have been making a score list since I commute the same stretch of road for considerable amounts of days and times. So far the cops have been partnering along the points I requested although it took a couple weeks to get their schedule rolled around. Now they wave and smile when I roll past the speed traps. Even if the extent of the police action was speeding tickets and an occasional personal greeting of the offender with a question it would still send a message. Tort and charges would be perhaps vengeful even if it would be justified to law. At least 2/3 of the near miss-ers that I have been able to talk to have not repeat offended. Even my little vivitar DVR 480 is mostly effective at scoring license plates. I wouldn't spend much more than $20 on a camera for it, but it works and its a good help for the memory.
the police are running speed traps as a result of your video evidence, and you've spoken to at least 3 close passers that no longer close pass bicyclists?
I'm amazed police are watching bicyclists' videos of close passes, and doing something about it.
#43
Shimano Certified
The police so far have not needed to see the video witness to accept citizen complaint/input. The local departments of the zones I go through have been fairly cooperative with constructive notes(like worst zones and times of day). They have told me prior to such input the success of trapping had been hit and miss at best. That to me sounds like a step in the positive.
#44
totally louche
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: A land that time forgot
Posts: 18,023
Bikes: the ever shifting stable loaded with comfortable road bikes and city and winter bikes
Likes: 0
Liked 10 Times
in
9 Posts
Vigilantism is the wrong word, but my impression:
some, perhaps many riders that choose to outfit their bikes to record motorists traffic transgressions have an inflated sense of their ability to orchestrate improved compliance to traffic law and safe passing standards by motorists.
Those beliefs are picayune.
Camera evidence may be invaluable in providing a record of the event when a serious road rage incident erupts.
I see an undercurrent of overzealous frustrated do-goodism over immutable elements while riding in traffic like close passers.
There's going to have to be a sea change in the judicial process before police departments start watching citizen videos of other road users, and begin chasing after motorists passing closer than 4 feet when there HASN'T been a collision.
Recording every commute and picking out bad driving, then 'informing' the authorities smacks of quixotic visions of being a self-appointed legal observer.
Like people driving around calling 911 everytime someone passes them in the fast lane going over the legal limit, or calling 911 to report every dog walker with their dog off their leashes.
Its a nice fantasy, but there's far better things to be doing after your rides than reviewing every purported close pass to then report to the authorities.
some, perhaps many riders that choose to outfit their bikes to record motorists traffic transgressions have an inflated sense of their ability to orchestrate improved compliance to traffic law and safe passing standards by motorists.
Those beliefs are picayune.
Camera evidence may be invaluable in providing a record of the event when a serious road rage incident erupts.
I see an undercurrent of overzealous frustrated do-goodism over immutable elements while riding in traffic like close passers.
There's going to have to be a sea change in the judicial process before police departments start watching citizen videos of other road users, and begin chasing after motorists passing closer than 4 feet when there HASN'T been a collision.
Recording every commute and picking out bad driving, then 'informing' the authorities smacks of quixotic visions of being a self-appointed legal observer.
Like people driving around calling 911 everytime someone passes them in the fast lane going over the legal limit, or calling 911 to report every dog walker with their dog off their leashes.
Its a nice fantasy, but there's far better things to be doing after your rides than reviewing every purported close pass to then report to the authorities.
#45
Vigilantism is the wrong word, but my impression:
some, perhaps many riders that choose to outfit their bikes to record motorists traffic transgressions have an inflated sense of their ability to orchestrate improved compliance to traffic law and safe passing standards by motorists.
Those beliefs are picayune.
Camera evidence may be invaluable in providing a record of the event when a serious road rage incident erupts.
I see an undercurrent of overzealous frustrated do-goodism over immutable elements while riding in traffic like close passers.
There's going to have to be a sea change in the judicial process before police departments start watching citizen videos of other road users, and begin chasing after motorists passing closer than 4 feet when there HASN'T been a collision.
Recording every commute and picking out bad driving, then 'informing' the authorities smacks of quixotic visions of being a self-appointed legal observer.
Like people driving around calling 911 everytime someone passes them in the fast lane going over the legal limit, or calling 911 to report every dog walker with their dog off their leashes.
Its a nice fantasy, but there's far better things to be doing after your rides than reviewing every purported close pass to then report to the authorities.
some, perhaps many riders that choose to outfit their bikes to record motorists traffic transgressions have an inflated sense of their ability to orchestrate improved compliance to traffic law and safe passing standards by motorists.
Those beliefs are picayune.
Camera evidence may be invaluable in providing a record of the event when a serious road rage incident erupts.
I see an undercurrent of overzealous frustrated do-goodism over immutable elements while riding in traffic like close passers.
There's going to have to be a sea change in the judicial process before police departments start watching citizen videos of other road users, and begin chasing after motorists passing closer than 4 feet when there HASN'T been a collision.
Recording every commute and picking out bad driving, then 'informing' the authorities smacks of quixotic visions of being a self-appointed legal observer.
Like people driving around calling 911 everytime someone passes them in the fast lane going over the legal limit, or calling 911 to report every dog walker with their dog off their leashes.
Its a nice fantasy, but there's far better things to be doing after your rides than reviewing every purported close pass to then report to the authorities.
#46
......Does there need to be contact? What would need to be in the video (plate, ID, etc)? Has anyone been successful with submitting a video of such an incident? (so far, it appears the answer is "No") BTW, I would never expect an officer to even consider pursuing a close passer, except in the most egregious situations (contact) or where they witnessed it.
Just yesterday, I recorded our local fire chief pulling out in front of me in a fire department vehicle, he realized his judgement error, and I was able to make an evasive maneuver to avoid hitting him.
After my experiences of extremely close passes, this incident wasn't in the ball park in comparison, with my pedaling on and the video clip will end up getting an honorable mention for chronological purposes and that is be as far as I will take it.
#47
Senior Member
NHTSA List of Aggressive Driving Programs by state: https://www.nhtsa.gov/people/injury/e...sive_index.htm
#48
Unlisted member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Chicagoland
Posts: 6,192
Bikes: Specialized Hardrock
Liked 433 Times
in
298 Posts
You are trying to paint everyone with the same broad brush, as if this is some sort of thread on crime-watch cyclists. I clearly spelled out that I simply want to know what level of reckless driving (videoed) would be required to get the police to act. Does there need to be contact? What would need to be in the video (plate, ID, etc)? Has anyone been successful with submitting a video of such an incident? (so far, it appears the answer is "No") BTW, I would never expect an officer to even consider pursuing a close passer, except in the most egregious situations (contact) or where they witnessed it.
#49
Where I live, any person can report a dangerous driver to the police provided they have some way to identify the vehicle (i.e., license plates) and charges will be filed. The case then goes to court and the complainant would have to testify which becomes a case of one person's word against another's. I am unaware of any legislation regarding the admissability of video evidence provided by the complainant; however, video evidence presented by the Crown (the state) such as red light cameras are often successfully challenged by the defendent.
#50
Never underestimate the tenacity of a motorist to find a way to circumvent your recording efforts if they are forewarned. Stealth is my preferred method, and to keep the situation as candid as possible.