Domane SL 5 vs Cervélo Caledonia 105
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2022
Location: Midwest USA
Posts: 5
Bikes: None at the moment
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Domane SL 5 vs Cervélo Caledonia 105
Hi all,
Not asking to help compare both bikes as I’ve had a chance to ride both in multiple sizes. I’m more asking advise on which I should purchase given a few variables.
Both are the same price up front, but there’s a few factors that concern me with both. The Cervélo concerns me because of it’s press fit BB and lack of dealers and or support. If I purchased a Cervélo it would be from a chain store called Erick’s Bike, Board and Ski.
The Trek I would be purchasing from an LBS. In the domane’s case I would need to replace the stock handlebar to a shorter reach and width, so that incurs a bit of added cost. Also, given I live in the Midwest I’m basically in Trek central so servicing it would never be an issue.
It’s quite the dilemma for sure, both are nice bikes for different reasons. The Cervélo has a snappy fun acceleration to it while still being comfortable, plus right of the box it would be set up and ready to go. The Trek Domane seems to be the ole reliable, it’s just I’d have to spend a bit more to make it work for me.
Not asking to help compare both bikes as I’ve had a chance to ride both in multiple sizes. I’m more asking advise on which I should purchase given a few variables.
Both are the same price up front, but there’s a few factors that concern me with both. The Cervélo concerns me because of it’s press fit BB and lack of dealers and or support. If I purchased a Cervélo it would be from a chain store called Erick’s Bike, Board and Ski.
The Trek I would be purchasing from an LBS. In the domane’s case I would need to replace the stock handlebar to a shorter reach and width, so that incurs a bit of added cost. Also, given I live in the Midwest I’m basically in Trek central so servicing it would never be an issue.
It’s quite the dilemma for sure, both are nice bikes for different reasons. The Cervélo has a snappy fun acceleration to it while still being comfortable, plus right of the box it would be set up and ready to go. The Trek Domane seems to be the ole reliable, it’s just I’d have to spend a bit more to make it work for me.
#2
Advocatus Diaboli
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Wherever I am
Posts: 8,869
Bikes: Merlin Cyrene, Nashbar steel CX
Liked 1,617 Times
in
1,064 Posts
Surprised a bit on your mention that the Trek would require a reduced reach handlebar. The Domane has probably one of the shortest frame reach ratios vs stack of the bikes out there. However, just looked at component list and see that the specced handlebars for any frame size above a 52cm has a 10cm reach (weird in this day and age where 8cm is fashionable).
Also, just a couple or so threads down from here, there's a Domane SL discussion -- seems that the stock bottom bracket ain't so great. Erik's is a good size chain, right? Good and bad -- if they have a good mech on staff, then no worries. I'd think a big chain has clout with the manufacturer if they go to bat for you on a warranty issue, while the Trek (owned?) store is also doing double-duty protecting Trek's interests? Maybe choose based on which color you like better?
Also, just a couple or so threads down from here, there's a Domane SL discussion -- seems that the stock bottom bracket ain't so great. Erik's is a good size chain, right? Good and bad -- if they have a good mech on staff, then no worries. I'd think a big chain has clout with the manufacturer if they go to bat for you on a warranty issue, while the Trek (owned?) store is also doing double-duty protecting Trek's interests? Maybe choose based on which color you like better?
#3
Fat n slow
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Saratoga, NY
Posts: 4,327
Bikes: Cervelo R3, Giant Revolt
Liked 2,113 Times
in
987 Posts
Hi all,
Not asking to help compare both bikes as I’ve had a chance to ride both in multiple sizes. I’m more asking advise on which I should purchase given a few variables.
Both are the same price up front, but there’s a few factors that concern me with both. The Cervélo concerns me because of it’s press fit BB and lack of dealers and or support. If I purchased a Cervélo it would be from a chain store called Erick’s Bike, Board and Ski.
The Trek I would be purchasing from an LBS. In the domane’s case I would need to replace the stock handlebar to a shorter reach and width, so that incurs a bit of added cost. Also, given I live in the Midwest I’m basically in Trek central so servicing it would never be an issue.
It’s quite the dilemma for sure, both are nice bikes for different reasons. The Cervélo has a snappy fun acceleration to it while still being comfortable, plus right of the box it would be set up and ready to go. The Trek Domane seems to be the ole reliable, it’s just I’d have to spend a bit more to make it work for me.
Not asking to help compare both bikes as I’ve had a chance to ride both in multiple sizes. I’m more asking advise on which I should purchase given a few variables.
Both are the same price up front, but there’s a few factors that concern me with both. The Cervélo concerns me because of it’s press fit BB and lack of dealers and or support. If I purchased a Cervélo it would be from a chain store called Erick’s Bike, Board and Ski.
The Trek I would be purchasing from an LBS. In the domane’s case I would need to replace the stock handlebar to a shorter reach and width, so that incurs a bit of added cost. Also, given I live in the Midwest I’m basically in Trek central so servicing it would never be an issue.
It’s quite the dilemma for sure, both are nice bikes for different reasons. The Cervélo has a snappy fun acceleration to it while still being comfortable, plus right of the box it would be set up and ready to go. The Trek Domane seems to be the ole reliable, it’s just I’d have to spend a bit more to make it work for me.
Did you look to see if there are any dealers within a reasonable dist?
Likes For phrantic09:
#4
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2022
Location: Midwest USA
Posts: 5
Bikes: None at the moment
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
There’s a couple Cervélo dealers within an hour from me. One is an LBS that sells in Felt, Cannondale, and Cervélo bikes. The other is Erik’s Bike Board and Ski which sells all sorts of sporting goods.
#5
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2022
Location: Midwest USA
Posts: 5
Bikes: None at the moment
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Surprised a bit on your mention that the Trek would require a reduced reach handlebar. The Domane has probably one of the shortest frame reach ratios vs stack of the bikes out there. However, just looked at component list and see that the specced handlebars for any frame size above a 52cm has a 10cm reach (weird in this day and age where 8cm is fashionable).
Also, just a couple or so threads down from here, there's a Domane SL discussion -- seems that the stock bottom bracket ain't so great. Erik's is a good size chain, right? Good and bad -- if they have a good mech on staff, then no worries. I'd think a big chain has clout with the manufacturer if they go to bat for you on a warranty issue, while the Trek (owned?) store is also doing double-duty protecting Trek's interests? Maybe choose based on which color you like better?
Also, just a couple or so threads down from here, there's a Domane SL discussion -- seems that the stock bottom bracket ain't so great. Erik's is a good size chain, right? Good and bad -- if they have a good mech on staff, then no worries. I'd think a big chain has clout with the manufacturer if they go to bat for you on a warranty issue, while the Trek (owned?) store is also doing double-duty protecting Trek's interests? Maybe choose based on which color you like better?
The LBS carries Trek, but also felt and surly bikes. However, yesterday I phoned them to ask if I could trade in my Emonda ALR 5 and the woman on the phone said Trek didn’t want them to take in anymore trade ins. I was a bit off put by this as they were seemingly willing to let a potential buyer walk away. In the chain stores case I would order the bike online and I could either have it delivered to my door or have it shipped to store to pick up.
#6
-------
Trek company stores in our area take trades. You get blue book value if in good condition.
#7
Senior Member
Bike service isn't like like taking a BMW to a Benz dealer. Any bike should should be able to adjust your gears or lube your chain.
Cervelo BB is not an issue.
Ole reliable sounds boring.
You did not say what size but the frames are pretty similar. The Trek has a shorter reach but generally Trek's have slacker seat tube angles and they should be pretty similar to the Cervelo. The Cervelo has more reach but less STA and less stack, so, it should feel slightly more sporty compared to the laid back ole reliable.
Greg would get the Cervelo
Cervelo BB is not an issue.
Ole reliable sounds boring.
You did not say what size but the frames are pretty similar. The Trek has a shorter reach but generally Trek's have slacker seat tube angles and they should be pretty similar to the Cervelo. The Cervelo has more reach but less STA and less stack, so, it should feel slightly more sporty compared to the laid back ole reliable.
Greg would get the Cervelo
Likes For GhostRider62:
#8
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2022
Location: Midwest USA
Posts: 5
Bikes: None at the moment
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Bike service isn't like like taking a BMW to a Benz dealer. Any bike should should be able to adjust your gears or lube your chain.
Cervelo BB is not an issue.
Ole reliable sounds boring.
You did not say what size but the frames are pretty similar. The Trek has a shorter reach but generally Trek's have slacker seat tube angles and they should be pretty similar to the Cervelo. The Cervelo has more reach but less STA and less stack, so, it should feel slightly more sporty compared to the laid back ole reliable.
Greg would get the Cervelo
Cervelo BB is not an issue.
Ole reliable sounds boring.
You did not say what size but the frames are pretty similar. The Trek has a shorter reach but generally Trek's have slacker seat tube angles and they should be pretty similar to the Cervelo. The Cervelo has more reach but less STA and less stack, so, it should feel slightly more sporty compared to the laid back ole reliable.
Greg would get the Cervelo
#9
Senior Member
For the Trek I would go for a 58cm and the Cervélo a 56cm. Both have relatively the same top tube effective length. The Cervélo is certainly more fun to ride, but I don’t know how it would feel after 50 plus miles. I’m someone who likes to go on long bike rides multiple times a week.
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: TC, MN
Posts: 39,521
Bikes: R3 Disc, Haanjo
Liked 9,462 Times
in
4,673 Posts
I owned a Domane SL5 - my R3, which has tighter tire clearance than the Caledonia, is a smidge less comfy than the Domane on 6+ hour rides, but still very comfy on 6+ hour rides. I'd go Cervelo all the way if the handling appeals to you.
Likes For WhyFi:
#11
serious cyclist
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Austin
Posts: 21,147
Bikes: S1, R2, P2
Liked 3,685 Times
in
2,028 Posts
The Domane has bigger tire clearance than the Caledonia. The Caledonia is more of a road bike that takes road+ tires, while the Domane is more of a full-on gravel bike. Which would you prefer? Both are good, but cross-shopping them is like comparing a 4Runner to an Accord.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: San Francisco, CA and Treasure Island, FL
Posts: 1,743
Liked 203 Times
in
135 Posts
For the Trek I would go for a 58cm and the Cervélo a 56cm. Both have relatively the same top tube effective length. The Cervélo is certainly more fun to ride, but I don’t know how it would feel after 50 plus miles. I’m someone who likes to go on long bike rides multiple times a week.
Likes For sfrider:
#13
Senior Member
I've had a few Cervelos and never any BB issues.
Likes For Seattle Forrest:
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: 757
Posts: 11,756
Bikes: Madone, Emonda, 5500, Ritchey Breakaway
Liked 5,688 Times
in
2,418 Posts
My C2 always made a popping sound on low rpm high torque situations. BB went kaput at 5000 miles, which is pretty good. Threw a new BB on there and it makes the same popping noise. That’s all I can contribute to this thread.
Dont get me started on Brake Rub.
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: 757
Posts: 11,756
Bikes: Madone, Emonda, 5500, Ritchey Breakaway
Liked 5,688 Times
in
2,418 Posts
Oh, My madone has the T47 bottom bracket which I think is the same as the domane you are looking at. That went kaput at 3,000 miles.
I guess I do have more to add to this thread.
#16
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Mich
Posts: 7,907
Bikes: RSO E-tire dropper fixie brifter
Liked 3,354 Times
in
2,118 Posts
if customer service is a factor, then Trek is not your brand.
I didn't put CS at the top of my list when I was looking for a dropbar CF bicycle. Ended up with the Domane. No regerts.
I didn't put CS at the top of my list when I was looking for a dropbar CF bicycle. Ended up with the Domane. No regerts.
__________________
-YMMV
-YMMV
#17
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: 757
Posts: 11,756
Bikes: Madone, Emonda, 5500, Ritchey Breakaway
Liked 5,688 Times
in
2,418 Posts
#18
-------
Customer service at the two Trek stores I use has been outstanding.
Several times stuff has been fixed/adjusted while I wait. I’ve never had to leave the bike. The charges for service have been anywhere from $0.00 to $25.00. That’s out of warranty.
Several times stuff has been fixed/adjusted while I wait. I’ve never had to leave the bike. The charges for service have been anywhere from $0.00 to $25.00. That’s out of warranty.
Likes For Mojo31:
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: 757
Posts: 11,756
Bikes: Madone, Emonda, 5500, Ritchey Breakaway
Liked 5,688 Times
in
2,418 Posts
same here. BB was replaced for free.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Mich
Posts: 7,907
Bikes: RSO E-tire dropper fixie brifter
Liked 3,354 Times
in
2,118 Posts
The lbs CS is fine, but Trek beyond that could do better.
__________________
-YMMV
-YMMV
#21
Full Member
If you like riding the Cervelo buy it! It’s a great bike. As others have said ongoing repairs can be any bike shop. If you have a warranty issue you’ll need to work through the dealer, but it’s really Cervelo you’ll be working with.
Here’s an interesting interview with someone from Cervelo about the Caledonia.
For instance, most endurance bike raise the front which impacts handling instead they lowered the bottom bracket (since you don’t need to pedal through corners if you aren’t racing) increasing the stack while maintaining the handling. The domane is also a great bike, but you should buy the one that puts the biggest smile on your face.
Here’s an interesting interview with someone from Cervelo about the Caledonia.
For instance, most endurance bike raise the front which impacts handling instead they lowered the bottom bracket (since you don’t need to pedal through corners if you aren’t racing) increasing the stack while maintaining the handling. The domane is also a great bike, but you should buy the one that puts the biggest smile on your face.
Likes For ratell:
#22
Senior Member
I don't know why service would be an issue except for warranty. The components aren't specific (in general) to any brand. Any good shop can take care of your bike.
I'd by the Cervelo if I liked it. If it didn't, I'd look at every other brand that is within reasonable distance, or online. I'll admit a bias against Trek. I just enjoy having stuff of equal or better quality and value that isn't the same as everyone else, so Cervelo would probably be an example of that as long as it suited me.
RE: press fit BB's We have two press fit BBs in the family - both PF30. I've never heard nor seen any problems with the original PF bearings. However, just for something to do a couple of winters ago, and thinking it was about time to replace them, I replaced the older bike's with a "screw together" PF 30 bottom bracket from Praxis. Liking that design when I built up a new PF30 BB bike last spring, I used a Wheels Mfg. version of the same sort of thing. They're similar but slightly different in application. But, if you're at all concerned with the press fit bottom bracket (unlikely as problems are), it's easily resolved with a thread together.
I'd by the Cervelo if I liked it. If it didn't, I'd look at every other brand that is within reasonable distance, or online. I'll admit a bias against Trek. I just enjoy having stuff of equal or better quality and value that isn't the same as everyone else, so Cervelo would probably be an example of that as long as it suited me.
RE: press fit BB's We have two press fit BBs in the family - both PF30. I've never heard nor seen any problems with the original PF bearings. However, just for something to do a couple of winters ago, and thinking it was about time to replace them, I replaced the older bike's with a "screw together" PF 30 bottom bracket from Praxis. Liking that design when I built up a new PF30 BB bike last spring, I used a Wheels Mfg. version of the same sort of thing. They're similar but slightly different in application. But, if you're at all concerned with the press fit bottom bracket (unlikely as problems are), it's easily resolved with a thread together.
Last edited by Camilo; 05-31-22 at 12:08 AM.
#23
Senior Member
OP is making Erik's bike shop sound like it's a big box Dick's Sporting Goods or similar. It isn't, it's a bike shop with small stores, albeit a small midwest chain. If Erik's now sells Cervelo (didn't last I checked, but it's been a while), then it shouldn't be an issue getting it serviced there...or anywhere else. FWIW I take both of my bikes (one Colnago, one Specialized) to Grand Performance in St. Paul. The former was bought there, the latter was bought at Erik's and is not sold by Grand. Nothing against Erik's, I just prefer Grand for service work.
#24
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2020
Location: North Florida
Posts: 575
Bikes: 2019 Specialized Diverge, 2021 Cervelo Caledonia
Likes: 0
Liked 408 Times
in
217 Posts
I bought a Caledonia ten months ago and really like it. It's possible that if I'd bought a Domane I'd like it just as much, but the Caledonia appealed to me more than competing bikes. I've had no BB issues, and with regard to longer rides have completed one Century on it with no issues. Two good bikes, so get the one that speaks to you. I heard the Caledonia calling my name, and it's been good so far.
#25
Senior Member
I have a Cervelo C3 which is very similar but older. It's a very fun bike to ride. I love the handling. It accelerates well. I can take it on dirt roads in the mountains around here and ride it pretty fast in good conditions.