Go Back  Bike Forums > Bike Forums > Bicycle Mechanics
Reload this Page >

Shimano XT instead of 105

Notices
Bicycle Mechanics Broken bottom bracket? Tacoed wheel? If you're having problems with your bicycle, or just need help fixing a flat, drop in here for the latest on bicycle mechanics & bicycle maintenance.

Shimano XT instead of 105

Old 06-12-07, 08:39 PM
  #1  
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 127
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Shimano XT instead of 105

I've contacted Sheldon Brown for advice. Asking him for replacements for my 105. He told me that 105 is nothing special, and his personal choice would be XT.


Thus, his personal choice would be mountain bike der for your road bike. Why?


Is XT better than 105, Ultegra, Dura Ace? I got the sense off him that it is stronger and shifts faster, but isn't lighter, but who cares. What are you thoughts on this one?
djSlvt is offline  
Old 06-12-07, 08:57 PM
  #2  
Cycling Skier
 
songfta's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Washington, DC
Posts: 620

Bikes: 2019 Moots Vamoots DR, 2008 Pedal Force ZX3, 2006 Jamis Eclipse, 1997 Marin Indian Fire Trail

Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
XT would shift nicely - of the long-cage options out there, it's probably among the best. I have a friend whose Trek Madone has XTR for a rear der (with a 11-30 ten-speed cassette) and a compact double (34-50) in the front - a setup he bought for last year's Death Ride. He says it shifts as well as his Dura Ace setup ever did (he still has the DA brifters and front der).
songfta is offline  
Old 06-12-07, 09:13 PM
  #3  
Gone, but not forgotten
 
Sheldon Brown's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Newtonville, Massachusetts
Posts: 2,301

Bikes: See: https://sheldonbrown.org/bicycles

Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 24 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 6 Times in 5 Posts
Originally Posted by djSlvt
I've contacted Sheldon Brown for advice. Asking him for replacements for my 105. He told me that 105 is nothing special, and his personal choice would be XT.


Thus, his personal choice would be mountain bike der for your road bike. Why?


Is XT better than 105, Ultegra, Dura Ace? I got the sense off him that it is stronger and shifts faster, but isn't lighter, but who cares. What are you thoughts on this one?
"Mountain bike" and "road bike" are marketing terms, not technical terms when you're talking about derailers and many other parts. The XT is what I would call a "wide range" derailer, vs. medium range (105 GS) or narrow range (105 SS). Wide range derailers were also formerly called "touring" models, but in the late '80s, the marketeers decided that "touring" was a worn-out term, so they re-named all of the touring stuff "mountain." It's a mistake to get suckered into thinking that there's some incompatibility where none exists.

The XT would permit a later change to a wide range cassette, while the so-called "road" models generally won't handle anything bigger than a 30 in back.

In terms of "level" (again, mainly a marketing issue) XT is the same "level" as Ultegra. Indeed, I replaced the Ultegra that came on my Raleigh Cadent 4.0 with an XT. I actually didn't change the gearing, so the XT is working at a small fraction of its capacity with the 12-25 10 speed and triple front.

I switched to the XT partly so that I would have the option of going lower in back at a later date, but mainly because it is the low-normal "RapidRise" version which provides slightly better downshifting. The use of a low-normal in back also reduced confusion when I would go back and forth between my Campagnolo equipped bikes and the Raleigh.

Sheldon "Reality, Not Marketing" Brown
Sheldon Brown is offline  
Old 06-12-07, 10:53 PM
  #4  
ThreadKiller
 
Evoracer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Disneyland, Ca
Posts: 229
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 3 Times in 2 Posts
I can vouch for the XT as it shifts just as well as my Ultegra. I climb a lot, and being a clyde, the lower gearing is a plus without going to a triple. I went with the top normal design to keep the same shifting pattern on the brifters.
Evoracer is offline  
Old 06-13-07, 04:41 AM
  #5  
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 127
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Perfect. I'm getting me a nice XT for the rear. They cost kind of same as 105, out of china.


I'm still looking for front der solution, I want same specs for front as XT only top pull. Tiagra I have totally bad. That's what caused me to break chain in the first place, because it wouldn't shift from 2nd to 3rd front.
djSlvt is offline  
Old 06-13-07, 02:27 PM
  #6  
I drink your MILKSHAKE
 
Raiyn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: St. Petersburg, FL
Posts: 15,061

Bikes: 2003 Specialized Rockhopper FSR Comp, 1999 Specialized Hardrock Comp FS, 1971 Schwinn Varsity

Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 3 Times in 3 Posts
One of the benefits of having an XT rear on a "road" bike is that it confuses and upsets the OCP roadies.
__________________
Raiyn is offline  
Old 06-13-07, 02:33 PM
  #7  
ThreadKiller
 
Evoracer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Disneyland, Ca
Posts: 229
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 3 Times in 2 Posts
Originally Posted by Raiyn
One of the benefits of having an XT rear on a "road" bike is that it confuses and upsets the OCP roadies.
Yup!
Evoracer is offline  
Old 06-13-07, 02:41 PM
  #8  
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 33,656

Bikes: '96 Litespeed Catalyst, '05 Litespeed Firenze, '06 Litespeed Tuscany, '20 Surly Midnight Special, All are 3x10. It is hilly around here!

Mentioned: 39 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2026 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1,095 Times in 741 Posts
Originally Posted by djSlvt
I'm still looking for front der solution, I want same specs for front as XT only top pull. Tiagra I have totally bad. That's what caused me to break chain in the first place, because it wouldn't shift from 2nd to 3rd front.
If you have a Tiagra (road) front derailleur how can you replace it with a top pull? Almost all road frames and fd's I know about require bottom pull shift cable routing.

If you are using STI shifters, you have to stay with a road front derailleur as MTB fd's have different geometry and don't shift well with STI brifters. That said, I have trouble believing the Tiagra fd was the cause of your chain breakage and that an MTB fd would do any better.

Sheldon is correct that "touring" and "MTB" rear derailleurs are pretty much the same animal except for marketing but the new name was really out of necessity. In the 1980's the touring market completely tanked and the MTB was just catching on and was destined to really be "the next big thing". Continuing to call wide range rear derailleurs "Touring" derailleurs was not going to work.

Also, as the MTB caught on, rear derailleurs were modified to meet their specific needs for ruggedness and dirt resistance. By now it's much more accurate to say that Touring bikes can use MTB rear derailleurs rather than the other way around.
HillRider is offline  
Old 06-14-07, 06:55 PM
  #9  
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 127
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Yea, looking back, I do believe the chain breaking was caused by a cross shift, or mis shift. I think I shifted front, and it didn't go through all the way, and then I shifted back...


All the while I was clanking like crazy on me. Now I know the signs...


When this new XT arrives, I'll install it, and test it while bike upside down. Then I go out there and learn to shift properly...



Do you think I could reuse the chian? It had 1 bent element, where it brocke. I fix that with some pliyers. It is straight now, and able to hook.
djSlvt is offline  
Old 06-14-07, 08:10 PM
  #10  
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Manhattan KS
Posts: 431

Bikes: 2001 Giant OCR w/105-10spd, Schwinn High-Plains Built for Commute plus 3 Others in Various Stages of Rebuild/Repair

Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
I wouldn't reuse the chain. Chains aren't that expensive and $7-10 USD is a whole lot cheaper than another new RD if a damaged (but not obviously so) link in that chain were to break...
Halthane is offline  
Old 06-14-07, 08:19 PM
  #11  
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 33,656

Bikes: '96 Litespeed Catalyst, '05 Litespeed Firenze, '06 Litespeed Tuscany, '20 Surly Midnight Special, All are 3x10. It is hilly around here!

Mentioned: 39 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2026 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1,095 Times in 741 Posts
Originally Posted by Halthane
I wouldn't reuse the chain. Chains aren't that expensive and $7-10 USD is a whole lot cheaper than another new RD if a damaged (but not obviously so) link in that chain were to break...
I agree. A chain with a damaged link is just waiting to break at an inopportune time. Replace it as soon as you can.
HillRider is offline  
Old 06-15-07, 10:40 AM
  #12  
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 76
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
what about the width difference between the 105/ultegra and the xt?
pothound
pothound is offline  
Old 06-15-07, 12:07 PM
  #13  
Gone, but not forgotten
 
Sheldon Brown's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Newtonville, Massachusetts
Posts: 2,301

Bikes: See: https://sheldonbrown.org/bicycles

Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 24 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 6 Times in 5 Posts
Originally Posted by pothound
what about the width difference between the 105/ultegra and the xt?
pothound
What width difference do you imagine there is?

Sheldon "Width?" Brown
Sheldon Brown is offline  
Old 06-15-07, 01:03 PM
  #14  
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 127
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
If I knew what that man knows before I bought my bike, I wouldn't buy it. Instead, I'd buy a frame, handle bars, seat post and seat, pedals, drive train, two derailers, other stuff, and build a bike I love to use for about the same money.
djSlvt is offline  
Old 06-15-07, 03:56 PM
  #15  
CRIKEY!!!!!!!
 
Cyclaholic's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: all the way down under
Posts: 4,276

Bikes: several

Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1589 Post(s)
Liked 687 Times in 365 Posts
Originally Posted by djSlvt
If I knew what that man knows before I bought my bike, I wouldn't buy it. Instead, I'd buy a frame, handle bars, seat post and seat, pedals, drive train, two derailers, other stuff, and build a bike I love to use for about the same money.
You can still do this for your next bike. It's a very rewarding experience so long as you don't do it primarily to save $.
__________________
"Surely one can love his own country without becoming hopelessly lost in an all-consuming flame of narrow-minded nationalism" - Fred Birchmore
Cyclaholic is offline  
Old 06-16-07, 01:01 PM
  #16  
Senior Member
 
04jtb's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: West Dorset, UK
Posts: 908

Bikes: 1983 Dawes Galaxy, 2006 Raleigh Airlite, 1982 Sun Solo (fixed)

Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Originally Posted by djSlvt
Do you think I could reuse the chian? It had 1 bent element, where it brocke. I fix that with some pliyers. It is straight now, and able to hook.
i broke a link the other day the guy at lbs said it was ok to take that link out and just reconnect it, as long as it wasnt too short in 1st place
__________________
Originally Posted by cc700
i jam my thumbs up and back into the tubes. this way i can point my fingers straight out in front to split the wind and attain an even more aero profile, and the usual fixed gear - zen - connectedness feeling through the drivetrain is multiplied ten fold because my thumbs become one with the tubing.
A group for all Dawes Galaxy owners to give and recieve information about them
https://flickr.com/groups/dawes_galaxy/
04jtb is offline  
Old 06-16-07, 04:07 PM
  #17  
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 33,656

Bikes: '96 Litespeed Catalyst, '05 Litespeed Firenze, '06 Litespeed Tuscany, '20 Surly Midnight Special, All are 3x10. It is hilly around here!

Mentioned: 39 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2026 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1,095 Times in 741 Posts
Originally Posted by 04jtb
i broke a link the other day the guy at lbs said it was ok to take that link out and just reconnect it, as long as it wasnt too short in 1st place
Reconnecting it with the proper pin or master link is a bit different than "straightening it with pliers".
HillRider is offline  
Old 06-16-07, 04:27 PM
  #18  
Senior Member
 
TallRider's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Fresno, CA
Posts: 4,454
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 128 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 12 Times in 10 Posts
I just built up one of my frames with 9-speed STI and a 12-25 cassette, and am using a 1995 XT long-cage rear derailer (labeled "8-speed"). Shifting works very well, although I don't need the extra capacity for either total chainwrap (53/39 double crank) or large rear cogs. It's just the derailer that I had sitting around.
__________________
"c" is not a unit that measures tire width
TallRider is offline  
Old 06-17-07, 05:01 AM
  #19  
Bike Builder
 
ruppster's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Marietta, OH
Posts: 265
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 8 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time in 1 Post
I have a Deore rear der on my CrossCheck. It shifts at least as well as the Tiagra it replaced. It was a spare in my tool box.
ruppster is offline  
Old 06-17-07, 07:03 AM
  #20  
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 76
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
my 105 rear hub assembly is 130mm. i think the xt rear assembly is 135mm. correct me if i'm wrong.
thank you
pothound
pothound is offline  
Old 06-17-07, 07:42 AM
  #21  
Senior Member
 
well biked's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 7,487
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 140 Post(s)
Liked 162 Times in 89 Posts
Originally Posted by pothound
my 105 rear hub assembly is 130mm. i think the xt rear assembly is 135mm. correct me if i'm wrong.
thank you
pothound
True, but your 105 rear hub will accept Shimano-compatible cassettes (road or mountain) and so will your XT hub. In other words, the cassettes don't mind if the hub they're going on is "road" or "mountain," the freehub body on the hub accepts either one-
well biked is offline  
Old 06-17-07, 11:23 AM
  #22  
Mad bike riding scientist
 
cyccommute's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 27,274

Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones

Mentioned: 150 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6147 Post(s)
Liked 4,092 Times in 2,325 Posts
Originally Posted by pothound
my 105 rear hub assembly is 130mm. i think the xt rear assembly is 135mm. correct me if i'm wrong.
thank you
pothound
Makes no difference. The hub width has no bearing on the rear derailer. The derailer only does what the shifter tells it to. You can use it on a 6/7/8/9 and maybe 10 speed cassette and on any hub spacing you can think of. The derailer doesn't care.
__________________
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!



cyccommute is offline  

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Thread Tools
Search this Thread

Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.